Scenario 3: Anonymous Blogging
Ms.
Gifford learned about a new blog that does not require the arduous
process of setting up individual accounts for each student. This seemed
like an easy way to jump into blogging as a class. Ms. Gifford talked
about acceptable use with her students but did not inform the principal
or parents of her instructional goals or objectives for using a class
blog. Because students did not have accounts, they were able to post
comments on the blog anonymously. Although, this protected student
privacy, it snowballed into a barrage of inappropriate and harassing
comments. Ms. Gifford quickly shut the blog down and went back to the
drawing board.
Ethical issues: Parents should be made aware of any time their child is going to be posting items onto the internet. Perhaps this is covered in this school's technology policy. However, parents should be made aware of the their child's internet usage.
Safety/Well being: If this site is open to the public and anyone can post with an anonymous user-tag it could be dangerous. Since there are many online predators, anyone can access this site and begin to interact with a student who may not know how to handle this situation. Therefore, this site would need to be closely monitored by the teacher if she wishes to continue using this open site.
Recommendation: I would recommend using a closed site that students need to create a user-tag and only those who are invited can access, read and comment on the posts. This way if there is any cyber-bullying or inappropriate actions the teacher can address this.
Real life connection: I do not have any real-life connections to this scenario. Does anyone have any they would be willing to share?
Scenario 5: Email Complication
Mr.
Lopez, a social studies teacher, has been using the same PowerPoint to
introduce content on the electoral-college for many years now. He
recently saw a Prezi his high school-age daughter created for a class
and asked her to teach him how to create a Prezi. He was able to link
images and video content instead of just text and found that his
students seemed more motivated and lively in a debate about voting
politics. He decided to have his 7th graders create Prezis in small groups outlining their main points for the election debate. What
Mr. Lopez discovered in the computer lab is that as students were
creating Prezi Edu accounts and told to use their school provided email
when registering, they could not activate their Prezi accounts because
the school email settings only allow emails internally, and therefore
cannot receive emails from outside the district. Mr. Lopez’s assignment
was suddenly dead in the water.
Recommendation: I would recommend to Mr. Lopex that he have his students create an e-mail that would be internal to the district. This way each student could create a prezi and have an active e-mail where they could communicate with their teachers. Many 7th graders do have e-mail accounts, but many do not. Those who have a-mail accounts would be able to create a second that would work inside the district.
Real life connection: When I was helping students use Moodle for the Biology course I co-taught many students needed to create google e-mail account and then create a moodle account. Although this took a lot of time upfront, it was really great for students to have access to moodle. Moodle is where lessons, assignments, study tools etc was kept for student use for preparing for tests or if they were absent or lost something.
Amanda, you've wrapped your brain around these scenarios and come up with some thoughtful observations and recommendations.
ReplyDeleteHey Amanda, I was looking at your real life connection to Scenario 5. All of my 5th graders have Moodle accounts that were set up by Gretchen Zahn at the district office. Since all MV students have MV email accounts, I just emailed her my class lists and their 6-digit ID#s and she set up their Moodle accounts quickly - it was super convenient. Their usernames were FirstnameLastname and their passwords were their 6-digit ID#s. I am not sure if this is an option for you at the middle school level, but I would look into it - it would save you and your students a lot of time! :)
ReplyDeleteAmanda, I really appreciate the way you formatted this blog post. It made it really easy for the reader to access your thoughts. I think your recommendation for scenario 3 is right on. It is important for the teacher to use a blog that has some administrative controls over when does and does not get published.
ReplyDelete